Great Circle Associates Firewalls
(May 1994)
 

Indexed By Date: [Previous] [Next] Indexed By Thread: [Previous] [Next]

Subject: Re: Network Sniffer
From: Eric . Vyncke @ csl . sni . be (Eric Vyncke)
Date: Tue, 24 May 1994 15:09:21 +0200
To: Firewalls @ GreatCircle . COM

>I have a basic question - Can a sniffer trace packets on different subnets ?
>If so can anybody shed some light as to which would be a better buy for
>less $$ or any free-ware software that can do the same.  Any help will >be 
appreciated.

As the author of a free MS-DOS sniffer, ETHLOAD, I can say:
1) it is _VERY_ easy to receive all frames on a Ethernet segment with a 
_VERY_ small program
2) due to firmware implementation, it is _OFTEN_ impossible to receive all 
frames on a Token Ring
3) it is _IMPOSSIBLE_ to receive frames transmitted on a Ethernet segment 
which is not local (my Sniffer in Belgium cannot receive your Ethernet 
frames!) or which is repeated. Obvious exceptions: if the frame is bridged 
to the destination via the LAN segment where the sniffer is tapped _OR_ if 
the frame is routed (IP, DECnet, ...) via the LAN segment where the sniffer 
is tapped.

Please be aware, that a TCP sniffing program can be developped in about 20 
hours on a PC (or TCPdump ported to another Unix in a matter of hours) and 
this program can get password (telnet, ftp, rlogin, ... send password as 
clear text) very _EASILY_...

Sorry, for the obviousness of the answer and comment :-)
---
Eric Vyncke,  Project Leader
Siemens Nixdorf - Centre Software de Liege - Belgium
EUnet: vyncke @
 csl .
 sni .
 be Phone: +32-41-201654 Fax: +32-41-201642


Indexed By Date Previous: re: Writing an RFP for a firewall
From: Quentin Fennessy <Quentin . Fennessy @ SEMATECH . Org>
Next: Re: Advice on Firewall Politics
From: long-morrow @ CS . YALE . EDU (H Morrow Long)
Indexed By Thread Previous: Re: Network Sniffer
From: Urban Surfer <HOLDREGE @ DCV4KD . PHS . COM>
Next: Re: Network Sniffer
From: Mark Fullmer <maf @ cob . ohio-state . edu>

Google
 
Search Internet Search www.greatcircle.com