Great Circle Associates Firewalls
(August 1994)
 

Indexed By Date: [Previous] [Next] Indexed By Thread: [Previous] [Next]

Subject: Re: Hacker's Site list
From: tdn @ tdn . xyplex . com (Thomas D. Nadeau)
Date: Thu, 25 Aug 94 14:01:07 EDT
To: MSHINES @ freh-02 . adpc . purdue . edu
Cc: firewalls @ GreatCircle . COM
In-reply-to: <3BEC26257ED @ freh-02 . adpc . purdue . edu> (MSHINES @ freh-02 . adpc . purdue . edu)
Reply-to: tdnadeau @ xap . xyplex . com

>ms> Is the problem sites, or individual users on the sites?  To me,
>ms> its the users who are the problem.  For example, we are an
>ms> educational institution, and encourage learning in the use of
>ms> computer technology. 

>ms> Do you kick domain *.purdue.edu off the net for this, or just the
>ms> errant user?  I think we're dealing with individuals behavior,
>ms> not the institutions.  I have no problem with blocking individual
>ms> users out...  some should be restricted for sure!

		That is exactly what the problem is -- users at a site, NOT
the entire domain.  Why penalize the entire domain because of the
actions of a few people? 

		Furthermore, we should not be responsible for the maintenance
of _any_ list of "bad" users or sites; instead it should be the
responsibility of the system administrator or administration authority
at the site in question to take appropriate action against the
person(s) who are cracking.  If the site management does not want to
take action against improper use of their networks, then either they
should be held responsible or their Internet connection should be
severed. 

		--tOm

-- 
/---------------------------------------------------------------------/
\                                                                     \
/  Thomas D. Nadeau                            ========      ======== /
\  Internetworking Software                      =======   =========  \
/  Xyplex, Inc.                                   =======  ======     /
\  295 Foster Street,                              ========  ==       \
/  Littleton, MA 01460                       -------=======  -------  /  
\                                                  ========  ==       \
/  Voice:  (508) 952-4837                         =======  ======     /
\  FAX:    (508) 952-4887                       =======   =========   \
/  email:  tdnadeau @
 eng .
 xyplex .
 com            ========    ==========  /
\                                                                     \
/---------------------------------------------------------------------/


References:
Indexed By Date Previous: Re: Hacker Site List?
From: tdn @ tdn . xyplex . com (Thomas D. Nadeau)
Next: Re: root account and routine work
From: Brent Chapman <brent @ mycroft . GreatCircle . COM>
Indexed By Thread Previous: Re: Hacker's Site list
From: "Michael S. Hines" <MSHINES @ freh-02 . adpc . purdue . edu>
Next: Re: Hacker's Site list
From: "Michael S. Hines" <MSHINES @ freh-02 . adpc . purdue . edu>

Google
 
Search Internet Search www.greatcircle.com