Great Circle Associates Firewalls
(July 1995)
 

Indexed By Date: [Previous] [Next] Indexed By Thread: [Previous] [Next]

Subject: Re: Review: "Safely Connecting to the Internet" Internetwork 7/95
From: David Schnardthorst <ds3721 @ strydr . com>
Organization: Stryder Communications, Inc.
Date: Tue, 25 Jul 1995 11:55:46 -0500 (CDT)
To: wyer @ telecheck . com
Cc: mjo @ dojo . mi . org, firewalls @ GreatCircle . COM
Address: 869 St. Francois, Florissant, Mo. 63031
Fax: (314)838-8527
In-reply-to: <9507251431 . AA08854 @ TeleCheck . com> from "wyer @ telecheck . com" at Jul 25, 95 09:31:25 am
Telephone: (314)838-6839

In the Original, wyer @
 telecheck .
 com Says
>
>>>> mjo @
 dojo .
 mi .
 org supposedly said:
> > :I feel that WIN/NT would make a sound, bullet-proof OS for a
> > :Firewall system.  Has anyone implemented?  Are there any
> > :commercial or home grown NT solutions available?  I would
> > :like to get a reprint of the article if some would please FAX.
> > 
> > No OS is bulletproof.  You feel that NT is secure?  Prove it.  
> > 
> > Effective firewall "systems" should consist of more than one piece.  I
> > think people make the mistake of equating a "system" with a single box.
> > 
> > That word "solutions" is deceptive industry newspeak which makes people
> > feel like you can pay someone to know what you want, someone who knows
> > and can tell you what all the problems are in your shop.  I don't think
> > any vendor has all the problems thought through, never mind "solutions".
> > 
> > Sorry if this seems rude or insulting.  Perhaps I should ask the question
> > of what it is that you "feel" that an NT box would to to help implement
> > the security policy of your sphere of responsibility/liability?
>--------------------
>Mike-
>
>I think that the work has already been done as far as proving that NT is 
>secure.  Correct me if I'm wrong, but hasn't it been C2 certified?  Please 
>spare me the flames if my memory doesn't serve me correctly.  I may be 
>thinking of VMS, which has been C2 certified.

So has SCO UNIX, but I wouldn't trust SCO as a firewall system.  

============================================================================
David Schnardthorst System Administrator  *  Phone: (314)838-6839
Stryder Communications, Inc.              *    Fax: (314)838-8527
869 St. Francois                          * E-Mail: ds3721 @
 strydr .
 com
Florissant, MO  63031                     *    URL: http://www.strydr.com
============================================================================


Follow-Ups:
References:
Indexed By Date Previous: Using product where you get source.
From: hickey @ pad-thai . cam . ov . com (Mark Hickey)
Next: Secure-ID & NTP vulerabilities
From: root @ garrison . com (Operator)
Indexed By Thread Previous: Re: Review: "Safely Connecting to the Internet" Internetwork 7/95
From: wyer @ telecheck . com
Next: Re: Review: "Safely Connecting to the Internet" Internetwork 7/95
From: Christian Wettergren <cwe @ Csli . Stanford . EDU>

Google
 
Search Internet Search www.greatcircle.com