Great Circle Associates Firewalls
(February 1996)
 

Indexed By Date: [Previous] [Next] Indexed By Thread: [Previous] [Next]

Subject: Re: Linux Disadvantages (Edited Question)
From: Jonathan Larmour <jlarmour @ origin-at . co . uk>
Date: Mon, 26 Feb 1996 14:42:12 GMT
To: Mustapha Obeid <musta @ eve . info . umoncton . ca>, FireWalls Mailing List <firewalls @ GreatCircle . COM>

At 14:58 24/02/96 -0400, Mustapha Obeid wrote:
> - What are the major three disadvantages of using Linux (1.2.3) instead
>   of a SunOS ?  That's disadvantages in terms of security (any serious
>   security holes yet discovered ?), performance, reliability and
>   processing speed.  Comparisons should be based on a usual  SPARC 20
>   and  a Pentium 75 MHz, whom one of them is supposed to be used as a
>   medium size commercial Internet server (where medium size = an
>   average of 40 active users at any time).

Although, I'm a Linux fan, and will endlessly testify to its stability,
security and maintainability if given the chance, I won't, coz my
flame-retardant suit is in the wash :-)

To get an idea of performance comparisons though, I recommend you look at:

http://www.silkroad.com/linux-bm.html

which has a list of BYTE UNIX benchmarks for various linux machines, and
also for Sparc ones. I suggest you look at the Sun Sparc 10, 50Mhz 128Mb RAM
(Duel CPU) entries. That machine scored 8.1. Pentium 75's have scored much
higher amounts. However, I have to ask why you are comparing machines that I
believe are vastly different in price? i.e. why only a P75?  I'm sure you
have your reasons, or my idea of Sun's prices is unrepresentative. However,
you will see that higher spec PC's slaughter the Sun benchmarks unequivocably.

Draw your own conclusions anyway.

Jonathan Larmour

P.S. The latest stable kernel is 1.2.13. If you are only using 1.2.3 it may
be worth upgrading to a new distribution (with ELF), before starting
anything major - assuming you do :-)
323 Cambridge Science Park, Origin UK, Cambridge, England. CB4 4WG.
Tel: +44 (1223)-423355    Fax: +44 (1223)-420724   E-mail: guess...
Disclaimer: This is not a disclaimer


Indexed By Date Previous: Re: Commercial SOCKS based firewall
From: Frederick M Avolio <avolio @ trusted . com>
Next: Re: dos sniffers?
From: peter @ nmti . com (Peter da Silva)
Indexed By Thread Previous: Linux Disadvantages (Edited Question)
From: Mustapha Obeid <musta @ eve . info . umoncton . ca>
Next: RealAudio and firewalls
From: richard . ellis @ kpmg . co . uk

Google
 
Search Internet Search www.greatcircle.com