Great Circle Associates Firewalls
(August 1997)
 

Indexed By Date: [Previous] [Next] Indexed By Thread: [Previous] [Next]

Subject: Re: Access-lists and routing performance
From: "Piotr Kolodziej" <pkol @ otago . gda . pl>
Date: Fri, 1 Aug 1997 17:42:37 +0200
To: <firewalls @ GreatCircle . COM>

> I suggest that you try access lists of thousands of
> lines where you need to traverse most of the list to get packets
> through.  20 seems like it is much too small, and if you keep matching 
> the lines at the top, it isn't a fair test of the opinion.
> ...
> Jeff Sedayao
> Intel Corporation
> sedayao @
 orpheus .
 sc .
 intel .
 com


Sure. I do not suppouse, that there's no sufficient number
of lines in access list that slows down the router.

But, I suppose, in most cases there's a possibility to place
the most heavily used clauses at the beginning of list
without making a security hole.

Of course, someone may not trust some features, such as
"established" key-word in tcp clauses.
(I'm not quite sure, but few years ago there was a problem with that.
Are there some problems now ?).
But if someone trusts it, then the greatest amount of traffic
is matched by that clause. So even if there's a need to apply list 
of thousands of lines, it should not dramatically slow down.

Finally, there is a question:
Is there a real need to apply such kind of lists, that in case of every 
packet thousands of lines must be traversed and it can't be optimized ???

Maybe, there's but I simply do not know it.

Piotr 
 +----------------------------+
 | Piotr Kolodziej            |
 | e-mail: pkol @
 otago .
 gda .
 pl  |
 +-------------------------------------------------+
 | ZUI Otago sp. z o.o.       | tel/fax:           |
 | ul. Marynarki Polskiej 148 | (+48 58) 43 06 22  |
 | 80-865 GDANSK, POLAND      | (+48 58) 43 05 19  |
 +-------------------------------------------------+


Indexed By Date Previous: Re: Message replies
From: Travis Low <tlow @ mindq . com>
Next: Re: FWTK proxys and ...
From: "Joseph S. D. Yao" <jsdy @ cospo . osis . gov>
Indexed By Thread Previous: Re: Access-lists and routing performance
From: sedayao @ orpheus . sc . intel . com (Jeff Sedayao)
Next: Re: Access-lists and routing performance
From: johns @ oxygen . house . gov (John Schnizlein)

Google
 
Search Internet Search www.greatcircle.com