Great Circle Associates List-Managers
(February 1996)
 

Indexed By Date: [Previous] [Next] Indexed By Thread: [Previous] [Next]

Subject: Re: Horror Story - is there a defense?
From: Jerry Peek <jerry @ ora . com>
Date: Sat, 17 Feb 1996 09:18:53 EST
To: bill @ biome . bio . dfo . ca (Bill Silvert), List-Managers @ GreatCircle . COM (List Managers)
In-reply-to: "Horror Story - is there a defense?" (bill@biome.bio.dfo.ca (Bill Silvert), Feb 17, 10:00) <9602171400.AA07310@biome.bio.dfo.ca>

Listproc 6.0 (and probably later versions) do a few things to stop
your problem of duplicate messages going to a list:

- it keeps the last 500 (I think) Message-IDs sent to each list, and
  also sent to listproc itself (administrative requests).  If a new
  message comes in with the same Message-ID as a previous message,
  listproc routes the message to the list owner or system manager.
  But some systems give the same Message-ID to more than one message
  (yes, this is wrong) and listproc rejects those too... I deal with
  that on a user-by-user basis; we have one user with that problem.

- it computes a checksum of each message body sent to a list.
  When a new message comes in, it compares the checksum to the last 500
  checksums; if there's a match, the message goes to the list owner.  
  By default, listproc uses the sum(1) utility, which sometimes gives
  the same checksum for different message bodies.  I hacked listproc
  to use the MD5 algorithm; we haven't had any problems since.

You could probably add code like that to your Majordomo.  The checksum
would probably be enough.  I haven't kept up on the lasest Majordomo
features; there are probably others like this in Majordomo already.

--Jerry, jerry@ora.com


Follow-Ups:
References:
Indexed By Date Previous: Horror Story - is there a defense?
From: bill@biome.bio.dfo.ca (Bill Silvert)
Next: Anonymous subscribers
From: haverber@winternet.com
Indexed By Thread Previous: Horror Story - is there a defense?
From: bill@biome.bio.dfo.ca (Bill Silvert)
Next: Re: Horror Story - is there a defense?
From: bill@biome.bio.dfo.ca (Bill Silvert)

Google
 
Search Internet Search www.greatcircle.com