Great Circle Associates Firewalls
(May 1995)
 

Indexed By Date: [Previous] [Next] Indexed By Thread: [Previous] [Next]

Subject: Re: NT as a Firewall
From: "Andrew T. Robinson" <atr @ netmaine . com>
Date: Tue, 30 May 95 12:10:18 EST
To: Firewalls mailing list <firewalls @ greatcircle . COM>

>>As an internet host, I wouldn't hesitate to use one. It's easy to setup
>>common Inet services on NT, most of the services are provided with the NT
>>resource kit or are included with NT OS. (You can download the resource kit
>>software from ftp.microsoft.com) FTP server comes with NT, HTTPS, WAISS,
>>GOPHERS, and DNS services are on the resource kit. The Remote Access Service
>>can provide dial-in PPP-access as well as IPX and NetBEUI, over telephone
>>and ISDN.

If you want a great non-UNIX Internet host, use OS/2 and TCP/IP V2 for OS/2,
which has the added advantage of being almost exactly bsd-like in its command
syntax, and actually implements those esoteric (sarcasm) protocols such as DNS
and SMTP, rather than writing wrappers around MS' "improved" protocols.

>>As an internet host, I wouldn't hesitate to use one. It's easy to setup
>
>It is obvious to me that you have never really done this. You're most
>likely basing this on marketing/advocacy propaganda, and never actually
>_tried_ to use NT for any of the above. Try it sometime, you'll
>see why trying to use NT for anything but a web server is a waste of
>time.

It isn't even good as a web server.  OS/2 with Fan's NCSA-based HTTPD 1.04 is
faster and easier to install and (as far as I'm concerned, and I'm willing to
back the contention up) inherently more secure. BSD/OS 2.0 rolls out of the box
with only a config_www as a fine HTTP server.

But I digress.  You neglect the sheep factor, which is why corporate America has
been waiting--what, four years now?--for MS to produce a 32bit multitasking OS 
when UNIX has been around for decades and (yes, I'm an OS/2 fan :-) OS/2 2.x has
been around since 1991/2.

Andy Robinson
NMI/IES

Indexed By Date Previous: Re: Would you trust a virtual private network?
From: Howard Berkowitz <hcb @ clark . net>
Next: Re: firewall router
From: dharter @ taz . dra . hmg . gb
Indexed By Thread Previous: Re: NT as a Firewall
From: Michael Nelson <mikenel @ netcom . com>
Next: spoof question.
From: JOHNSON @ neu . edu

Google
 
Search Internet Search www.greatcircle.com