Great Circle Associates Firewalls
(October 1996)
 

Indexed By Date: [Previous] [Next] Indexed By Thread: [Previous] [Next]

Subject: Re: [chris michael: firewalls and the clue-challenged]
From: Mike Shaver <shaver @ neon . ingenia . ca>
Date: Tue, 29 Oct 1996 09:52:54 -0500 (EST)
To: sazah @ ibu . sj . nec . com (Sunny Azah)
Cc: firewalls @ greatcircle . com
In-reply-to: <199610290055 . QAA18600 @ vegas . ibu . sj . nec . com> from "Sunny Azah" at Oct 28, 96 04:55:57 pm

Thus spake Sunny Azah:
> The whole point of commercial firewalls should be to make a reasonable
> level of security as inexpensive and simple as possible.

Perhaps.

I suspect that most vendors see the point of commercial firewalls as a
way to generate revenue, and that far too many buyers see the point of
commercial firewalls as due diligence.

> The firewall should be a "security expert in a box."

I don't think that's really feasible.
A `security expert' (often known as a `Firewall Consultant(tm)') asks
questions, pokes around, makes assumptions based on context and then
recommends a course of action.  Notice that a security expert does
not, typically, hold two pieces of ethernet and regulate traffic.

A firewall is far more analogous to a wrench than a mechanic.

> The rest of the market needs something secure, reliable,
> and easy to use.

So, you want something complex enough to handle the intricacies of
just about every network (and security policy, and `threat
environment'), but which is simple enough that Aunt Thelma can just
plug it in and have it go.

Dessert topping _or_ floor wax, I fear.  At least until those wacky AI
boys catch up.

Mike
(don't mind me...another day, another `firewall protecting idiots from
themselves' nightmare)

-- 
#> Mike Shaver (shaver @
 ingenia .
 com) Ingenia Communications Corporation 
#>       Chief System Architect -- Head geek -- System exorcist        
#>                                                                     
#>   "Have you considered a life?  I hear they're quite affordable     
#>          these days." --- shields @
 tembel .
 org                        


References:
Indexed By Date Previous: Re: NAT options (was running out of IP addresses)
From: uhaas @ tsg-usa . com
Next: Re: The BEST Firewall
From: "Bryan D. Boyle" <bdboyle @ erenj . com>
Indexed By Thread Previous: Re: [chris michael: firewalls and the clue-challenged]
From: sazah @ ibu . sj . nec . com (Sunny Azah)
Next: Microsoft Proxy Server
From: Chris Pugrud <ChrisP @ steldyn . com>

Google
 
Search Internet Search www.greatcircle.com