Great Circle Associates Firewalls
(June 1997)
 

Indexed By Date: [Previous] [Next] Indexed By Thread: [Previous] [Next]

Subject: FW-1 rule enforcement on specific interface
From: Vivek Sajip <ttwvms @ aie . lreg . co . uk>
Date: Mon, 23 Jun 97 16:47:26 BST
To: firewalls @ GreatCircle . com

Can someone please help with the following question concerning
Checkpoint's FW-1 software:
 
Is it possible to restrict the enforcement of a rule to
a specific interface on the firewall gateway, and if so, how
do you do it ?
 
The firewall gateway in question has 3 (physically distinct) network 
interfaces: internal, external, DMZ.
A http server sits on the DMZ.
We wish to allow external (Internet) users to access the http server.
We wish to prevent internal users from accessing the http server.
The internal networks are numerous and we do not wish to list them all as
objects in the network objects database.
So something like the following won't do (because the group "INT NET"
consisting of all internal networks is too complex)
 
Source  Destination  Services  Action Install On
 
Any     http-server  http       allow gateway
INT NET http-server  http       deny  gateway
Any     Any          Any        deny  gateway   (default rule)
 
We wish to have a rule  something like:
 
Source  Destination  Services  Action Install On
 
Any     http-server  http      allow  gateway's external interface 
Any     Any          Any        deny  gateway   (default rule)
 
In this case the default rule would prevent internal users from
accessing the http-server without us having to add a specific
rule for internal networks.
Can it be done ?
 
Our FW-1 technical support have  been looking at this
question for weeks and have finally come back and (after talking
to Checkpoint) said that it can't be  done unless we list all the internal
network objects in a group "INT NET".
 
The Firewall 3.0 manual implies that it can be done :
 
"The only way to restrict the enforcement of a rule to a specific
interface is by using INSPECT" FW-1 v3.0 manual P355
 
but there are no details of how to do it using INSPECT.(The GUI
doesnt allow you to do it.)
 
Vivek Sajip
ttwvms @
 aie .
 lreg .
 co .
 uk


Follow-Ups:
Indexed By Date Previous: Security & Policy Architecture
From: Paul Ferguson <pferguso @ cisco . com>
Next: Re: Is six weeks long enough to become a security expert
From: m* <mark @ novare . net>
Indexed By Thread Previous: Security & Policy Architecture
From: Paul Ferguson <pferguso @ cisco . com>
Next: NetRoad Firewall?
From: "Gerhard C. Forster" <Gerhard . Forster @ supratec . com>

Google
 
Search Internet Search www.greatcircle.com