Great Circle Associates List-Managers
(July 1993)
 

Indexed By Date: [Previous] [Next] Indexed By Thread: [Previous] [Next]

Subject: Re: UNIX listserver
From: morgan @ engr . uky . edu (Wes Morgan)
Date: Thu, 8 Jul 93 16:29:54 EDT
To: List-Managers @ GreatCircle . COM

>> >As far as fairness to the authors, I don't think the property rights
>> >go as far as to the name "listserver".
>> 
>> The name "ListServer" is in use by the MLM implemented by Tasos.
>> I sincerely hope you respect his use of that word.
>
>Now I'm *really* confused.  We *use* Tasos' implementation.  So, does
>that mean I have the right (and meet your standards of politeness) to
>use the name "listserver"???  If so, then I *must* use the address
>"listserv" as well.  You see, we have a Unix host on the BITNET, and
>some BITNET sites have 8-character restrictions on addresses.  Now
>what do you suggest?

Quite frankly, I suggest that we find something more meaningful to
discuss.  We can all find naming clashes; look at the current flame-
war in cracking/phreaking circles over some 15-year-old's appropria-
tion of the name "Legion of Doom."  

How many of us call our HP-UX systems "Unix"?  How about those Macs
running A/UX?  Are they "Unix"?  PRIMIX?  Solaris?  HCX/UX?  On and
on and on......*sigh*...........we could go on all summer long with 
this stuff.

I've seen this particular flamewar crop up on BITNET lists (such as
LSTOWN-L and NODEINFO), Usenet newsgroups, and (most recently) here 
on List-Managers.

All the world is not Eric Thomas' Revised LISTSERV, nor is it Tasos'
implementation.  Gee, what if I run Majordomo and call it something
like "mailserv@engr.uky.edu"?  What if I write an exact Unix clone
of LISTSERV?  Arrgh.....

--Wes


Indexed By Date Previous: Re: UNIX listserver
From: "Michael H. Morse" <mmorse@z.nsf.gov>
Next: Re: UNIX listserver
From: "F. Scott Ophof" <Ophof@CS.UWindsor.Ca>
Indexed By Thread Previous: Re: UNIX listserver
From: rick@ssg.com (Rick Emerson)
Next: Re: UNIX listserver
From: "F. Scott Ophof" <Ophof@CS.UWindsor.Ca>

Google
 
Search Internet Search www.greatcircle.com