Great Circle Associates Majordomo-Users
(April 1998)
 

Indexed By Date: [Previous] [Next] Indexed By Thread: [Previous] [Next]

Subject: Re: HTML-enabled mailing lists (fwd)
From: chip @ pcc . com (Chip Hart)
Date: Mon, 30 Mar 1998 10:04:02 -0500 (EST)
To: Majordomo-Users @ GreatCircle . COM

Wayne McGuire spoke:
> Many leading mail readers, like Eudora, have
> already fully embraced HTML standards (and will
> soon embrace XML standards). This trend has very
> much the feel of an unstoppable revolution in
> personal computing.
	
	While we're flying way off topic here, I'd love to ask exactly
	where I can find these "HTML standards" that everyone refers to.

	Oh, I know about the W3C and HTML 3.2, etc., but those
	"standards" behave VERY differently from IE 3.0 to IE 4.0 to
	Netscape 3.0 to Netscape 4.0 to Netscape 4.0 in AIX, etc.,
	etc., etc.  I can't believe that people are so willing to
	embrace a standard that is neither standard nor appropriate
	for the medium of email.

	HTML was designed to be a HYPERTEXT markup language.  While its
	use as such in an email message is, perhaps, interesting,
	that's not what I see it used for most of the time.  The
	majority of HTML-embedded email messages I see use HTML for
	color coding, font changing, boldfacing, etc.  BIG WHUP. 
	Anyone care to point me to an example of a "revolutionary" use
	of HTML in email?  Something that makes the effort of wading
	through all the CRAP worthwhile?  
	
	Just because some of us would like to be more conservative in
	our embrace of *some* new technologies, doesn't mean we're
	Luddites.  That would be akin to blaming those of you who think
	HTML-email is wonderful for the VHS-format or Win95 (I hope the
	analogy is clear).  Further, just because email readers a, b, or
	c are HTML-"ready" doesn't mean that it's a good thing.  It just
	means that someone is trying to get more people to use their
	program - there's a big difference between selling/producing the
	most software and selling/producing the *best* software (see
	previous analogy).

-- 
Chip Hart                           *                          chip@pcc.com
People's Computer Company           *              http://www.pcc.com/~chip
15 Pinecrest Drive                  *                     Work:800-722-7708
Essex Junction, VT  05452           *                     Fax: 802-872-8214



Follow-Ups:
Indexed By Date Previous: Re: Simplifying email addresses
From: David Smith <smithd@blkbox.com>
Next: long header fields
From: Bill Heiser <bill@bh.org>
Indexed By Thread Previous: RE: MajorCool: Getting It!
From: "King, Arron" <kinga@odc.edu>
Next: Re: HTML-enabled mailing lists (fwd)
From: Christopher Lindsey <lindsey@ncsa.uiuc.edu>

Google
 
Search Internet Search www.greatcircle.com