Great Circle Associates Network-Automation
(April 2005)
 

Indexed By Date: [Previous] [Next] Indexed By Thread: [Previous] [Next]

Subject: Re: available network automation tools
From: "Francis Liu" <Francis . Liu @ optus . com . au>
Date: Wed, 13 Apr 2005 10:06:16 +1000
To: "Daniel Hagerty" <hag @ linnaean . org>
Cc: <network-automation @ greatcircle . com>
Thread-index: AcU/mOOzr20KEKDBSuOBYq06IDCzUQAIsSPA
Thread-topic: available network automation tools

>     If "your" ontology was "correct", you could write one and be done
> with it.  This is not a precisely correct expression of my meaning
> however; you'll always have to be changing ontology at some level:
> that's the point after all.
> 
>     The more precisely correct expression is that you could write a so
> called "top level ontology" or "ontology in the domain of domains".
> Use this top level ontology (or things derived from it) to describe
> your (changing) network ontology in.  If you specify top level
> correctly, it is timeless, even when the ontologies within it are not.
> 
>     The ability to produce this top level ontology is an area of open
> debate.  I appear to fall firmly within the camp that says "this is
> possible, want to see how?".

If there exists a current body of work that is sufficient and necessary,
we, the practitioners in the field, will work with it. We don't
necessarily want/need something that is "complete" (and possibly more
complex). Workable is great. Flaws can be fixed later, in a revision
somewhere.

>     We're all interested in solutions to our configuration problems.
> I'm quite happy to hear that you've produced a model that works for
> you.  The model I need is a much bigger hammer.

Not a math scientist, just an admin,

Francis

Indexed By Date Previous: Re: available network automation tools
From: Daniel Hagerty <hag@linnaean.org>
Next: Re: available network automation tools
From: Andrew Fort <andrew.fort@gmail.com>
Indexed By Thread Previous: Re: available network automation tools
From: "Network.Security" <Network.Security@target.com>
Next: Welcome, and BoF at USENIX next week
From: Brent Chapman <Brent@GreatCircle.COM>

Google
 
Search Internet Search www.greatcircle.com